Cinema Signal:

The Statement:
The Book that inspired this movie.
by Brian Moore

. "The Statement"

Centering on the case of a convicted nazi war criminal, this commercially risky directorial effort by Norman Jewison (Moonstruck) from a screenplay by oscar winner Ronald Harwood (The Pianist) asks us to sympathize with the man's humanity while condemning him for his past. But it hopes for too much.

The words inhumanity and nazi are virtually synonymous and in an initial sequence we see French official Pierre Brossard give the order to execute seven Jews lined up against a wall. It's June, 1944. It's a familiar scene, a re-creation from newsreels. Brossard is a member of the Vichy government, the France that sided with the nazis and supported them in every way.

But our story is not about that time. We pick it up in 1992, after Brossard received a full pardon for his crimes from the succeeding president of France. A secret vigilante group not in sympathy with this despicable act, is sending out assassins to correct that injustice. They've now located a 48 years older Brossard, living as unnoticeable a life as he can with the support of former Vichy colleagues and right-wing members of the Catholic church.

The first of several attempts on Brossard goes bad when hit man David Manenbaum (Matt Craven) proves his ineptness against the wily and seasoned Brossard, who beats him to the trigger. Brossard learns the identity of the would-be killer by emptying his pockets. He then finds a printed note in the form of a formal statement (providing the movie title) meant to be placed on his own dead body. It declares that this act of justice (killing him) was done in the name of the Jews who died by his act. Brossard, ever fearful, now knows he's an active target and goes on the run, imploring his contacts for more money and protection.

But killers are not the only ones on Brossard's trail. Following a renewal of a charge against him for crimes against humanity, Paris judge Annemarie Livi (Tilda Swinton), a lady with a Catholic mother and a Jewish father is trying to track him down with the help of law enforcement officer Colonel Roux (Jeremy Northam), which adds to the thriller aspect of the story as it intercuts between the factions chasing the elusive fugitive and getting us deeper and deeper into the labyrinths of protection surrounding such escapees from the guilt of 77,000 Jews who died in Vichy France.

Livi's intention goes beyond Brossard, however, as she is resolved to expose those French in influential positions of wealth and political standing who are protecting all the Vichy vermin who remain. In following her path of investigation, she gets into the company of some insidious deceivers backing the man on the run, and the support structure for him from within the precincts of mother church.

All of which is based on a true story. Brian Moore's novel of 1997 recounts the case of Paul Touvier, a Vichy functionary who eluded capture after a sentence of death with the aid and comfort of the church and official sympathizers until 1989.

Jewison's depiction of a fugitive who repeatedly gets the upper hand against what should be presumed to be trained killers is a strain on credulity and does less than well in persuading us of the situation's reality. Caine, while obviously seriously absorbed in showing us this monstrosity of a man, ultimately can't go against the grain of his character's unmasked evil and desperate means of avoiding penalty. His portraint of sniveling assertiveness, abject pleading, praying, bullying and fear, however shaded, doesn't absorb us much in his plight. We want the bugger to die.

A judge turned investigator and detective sidekick seems a contrived pairing to elevate the tensions and pace of the story. Though there's nothing illegitimate in that, if the judge had been written as a more credible and dimensional figure the dramatic stakes would be elevated. Certainly the estimable Swinton could manage that side of the emotional equasion, as she did expertly in "The Deep End" in 2001. This very interesting actress swings in a wide creative arc, going from such mainstream fare as this to worlds of experimental strangeness as "Orlando" and, more recently, a sci-fi mess called, "Teknolust."

The idea of centering on a despicable character, a dramatic risk at best, diminishes the effect of a very worthy film's intention of exposing a piece of history that needs to feel the light of day, as well as our outrage and condemnation of a network of priests who subverted the guilt of crimes against humanity and, therefore, share it. But, the absence of a character to compel a rooting for vindication impairs the impact. Were there an emotional lynchpin somewhere in sight, it might have made its points with the gripping effect it aspires to.

Click for full list of movie reviews

                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  

The Soundtrack album

Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants

Michael Caine as Pierre Brossard
A nazi on the run

Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)
Best selling DVDs!