INTERACTIVE (Rate the Review)
Subscribe to our update feeds:
Cinema Signal: Not quite a green light but has elements of strong appeal for a limited audience.
. "Snow White and the Huntsman"

You don't need much more than the poster art to tell that this isn't your childhood's Snow White. Someone apparently thought that the children's book could be taken to a heavier and darker level for modern adults. What we get here is the nightmare version on steroids, set in an earlier age when everyone was pretty much argumentative, sour, combative, distrustful, and just out for themselves. A wretched lot. But none more so than this Queen.

Yes, it's Queen Ravenna (Charlize Theron, "In the Valley of Elah") who's the biggest hater of them all. Amped up with magic powers, her dangerous, devoted brother Finn (Sam Spruell), her army, and majestic guile, she takes over any kingdom she wishes to rule on a journey to reign over the continent. In this case, it's King Magnus's (Noah Huntley) in her sights, and by presenting herself as a helpless captive she captivates his heart and becomes his queen. First order of business? The immediate installation of her mirror.

"Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the fairest of them all?" she asks. And the answer forthcoming from it is a pleasing one, but there are reservations. Soon it'll be warning that her beauty, as well as her powers, will be curtailed by someone very close... her stepdaughter, Snow White (Kristen Stewart) .

Not being someone to stand on ceremony or subtlety, she sets her troops out to crush 'em all, though a few escape. The result is the kind king's banishment with his young son, Prince William (Sam Claflin), Snow White's childhood friend. The escapees live to tell the tale but become exiles, all.

Snow White, however, doesn't make it out of the castle. Word spreads that she's dead. But, the queen has a need for her rival in beauty. She imprisons her nemesis in the tallest tower of the castle, and there she remains for years, becoming more beautiful with each one (now Kristen Stewart).

Ravenna, showing signs of age, grows impatient to acquire immortality by devouring Snow White's heart. But before she can taste of her captive, the young beauty escapes the castle through a secret passageway and makes her way into the Dark Forest which is inhabited by some pretty scary, hostile creatures both vegetable and human.

The wicked queen is furious and attacks brother Finn for allowing the escape. He must find a "huntsman" to search for her immediately, and comes he up with the unsavory, independent Eric (Chris Hemsworth, "The Avengers"), one of the few who know the Dark Forest and has come out of it alive. This wooly but handsome guy relents, goes after his prey, finds her and winds up becoming Snow White's protector. He teaches his ward skills of combat and, in the process, becomes emotionally involved.

The staging of all of this is filmmaking at its technical best -- from the standpoint of effects, spectacle, action and craftsmanship. But this expertise ends with casting and writing (by Evan Daughety and Martin Solibakke) and, to a critical degree, to Rupert Sanders' direction.

One of the more interesting choices was Theron for a part that was certain to give us a look at her in a previously unexplored genre. And, indeed, her beauty and capacity for cold brutality paid off. (A great deal more than misconceived first choices, like Felicity Jones and Winona Ryder, would have, I'll wager).

Similarly, Hemsworth is a far more suitable Huntsman than the inconceivable first choice candidate Johnny Depp, which might have converted the whole tone of the picture into a Jack Sparrow farce.

But, though these initial casting choices were clearly inept, the worst of all was the casting of Stewart in the key role. Now, this is an actress whom the camera loves as it does few others. And, I've seen this gorgeous actress in more than the Twilight series, and have come to respect her talent in such work as "The Yellow Handkerchief" and "Welcome to the Rileys." Her shyly reserved loveliness plays well in such modest atmospheres and she can be affecting. But what she shows in the daunting demands of a Snow White, directly up against the likes of a monster of guile and evil like Theron's majestic, entirely ruthless, larger than life villain, is that she doesn't hack it. Not even close. Blah.

As the story proceeds to its eventual payoff, when the demands of acting turn serious for the Joan of Arc character that is Snow White, things begin to fall apart. Our expectations are a great deal higher than Stewart is capable of delivering. At the very end [SPOILER AHEAD], at Snow White's crowning moment, it becomes nothing more than spectacle. Well, great for the costume, art and cinematography departments. But what Stewart is doing with this glorious moment is sheer vacuity. In the moment that she at last ascends her throne, adored by all and most of all by her savior, Eric, what does she say? She stares out at her subjects and says... nothing, and the film goes down to utter defeat.

"John Carter" land.

This role doesn't require sweet honesty of its star, but a growling demand for retribution and justice -- for which direction, writing, action choreography and, possibly, her own talent, let her down.

Just picture what an excitement this film could have been with the likes of Emma Stone, Blake Lively, Elizabeth Banks, Rachel McAdams or the always feisty Ellen Page in this role! You needed someone with the looks and the grits to move the furniture.

For a film with the revisionist audacity that this one had, I can't think of a greater disappointment in its realization. It's so obvious that Sanders and staff were putting marquee value ahead of any functional calibration of realizing the potentials of their screenplay. Too bad. Stewart does ensure a healthy boxoffice (so many tween and teen fans), but little praise from the critics or the critical.

Click for full list of movie reviews





                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  

Won't YOU join the discussion about this movie and/or review?
Worries? Concerns? Want to know more? Just click the button...


Opinion Section
Comments from readers:
Well written
I've seen the movie and disagree with the review
Site rating: 5
Have to agree with some of it, however Kristen Stewart always plays herself. She has the same facial expression in every movie she's in. I don't agree with your assessment of her, the girl just can't act.
                                                           ~~ Gues 
Steward [sic] could have nailed it, had she been given the chance. Instead, the script squandered the time with too much dark forest gimickery, repetetive violence, and more secondary characters than it had time to develop. You have blamed your actress for the failings of the script.
                                                           ~~ Lynnette M.P. 
[Thanks for your input, Lynnette. Always enjoy thoughtful reader feedback. But, we do have a strong disagreement, though I won't go as far as Gues did (above). Having been on many a set and having worked with many an actor, my intuition about the ending scene is that there was a scripted speech for the newly installed queen but that by this time in the production the director realized that Stewart would be incapable of giving it the power such a moment would demand. No speech would protect Stewart from embarassing herself and the film. Either that or they tried it and it ended up on the cutting room floor. So, instead, we see her mute and sort of dumbfounded sitting on the throne that she presumably worked so hard to get. For a hint at what such a role can be, see the wondrous Cate Blanchett as Elizabeth I in "Elizabeth." If you're going to judge acting, let me suggest, use the best as your standard. ~ Ed.]

Very well written
I've seen the movie and agree with the review
Site rating: 9

Does Kristin Stewart ever close her mouth? Her gape-mouthed blankness and heavy breathing seem to be the range of her emotions. That doesn't mean she's unlikeable, only that she lacked the chops to bring life to a role that was not made any meatier by the lack of meaningful dialogue.

                                                           ~~ Linda 
Very well written
This review will influence me to read more by this reviewer
I've seen the movie and I agree with the review
Site rating: 7
This is one of the most thoughtful (and I believe, accurate) reviews I have read about this movie. You are right, it could have been so much more, but the priorities were out of place. The casting stages you list show how confused the creative team was while crafting it. I just read your response to Lynnette, and I can see how the ending may have happened just as you described.
                                                           ~~ Jenne F. 
Poorly written
I've seen the movie and I agree with the review
I think you should not reveal the plot in so much detail when giving a review. It's like reading cliffnotes, when you are done, you don't need to read the book. But I do agree with the basic elements of the review. I blame much of the poor quality of the movie on the script but perhaps they didn't give Stewart much to say because she just doesn't have the acting chops to say anything with meaning, flair and emotion.
                                                           ~~ Alex Solomotis 
Well written
This review will influence me to read more by this reviewer
I've seen the movie and I agree with the review
Site rating: 6
"Someone apparently thought that the children's book could be taken to a heavier and darker level for modern adults."
Funny, I would say that would be the Brothers Grimm. Their original story featured an evil queen who ate the lungs and liver of the boar the huntsman killed believing it was Snowwhite. I am happy to finally have a departure from the Disney version stories. Often Disney distorted them to make them more "family friendly" not the other way around.
I would agree however the Stewart was not good in this movie. She often resorts to running her hands through her hair and breathing heavy to show any signs of emotion in her characters and it is a bit annoying. I was happy they explained it was beauty in her HEART not her appearance that made her fairer than Ravenna as well.
                                                           ~~ Sarah 
Very well written
I've seen the movie and I disagree with the review
Site rating: 4
I disagree with your assessment of Kristen Stewart's preformance. She did the best she could with the poor script and she had barely any lines in it at all! The characters in this movie were seriously underdeveloped. This movie could have been much better.
                                                           ~~ Jan
[Thanks much for writing and explaining your disagreement with my assessment of Stewart's performance. While I agree that the script had shortcomings, I believe it had to do with Stewart's inability to handle what was originally written for her character. It's standard in movie making for the writer to accomodate dialogue to specific actors' style and range once they are cast. The process of doing that for Stewart's limitations, therefore, greatly diminished the level of writing. Why else was she mute on the throne--do you really believe the writters didn't have a big speech written for her at this amazing moment?! Also note how powerfully written Theron's dialogue was. You just can't blame the writers for the weaknesses of an actor. But, we have to see this in two ways: On the one hand, casting her was a big sacrifice; on the other hand, pandering to her fans and casting her was a brilliant move commercially, and it paid off at the boxoffice, bigtime!]



Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants




Chris Hemsworth and Kristen Stewart
The Huntsman and his charge, Snow White.

Quick Note, yo:
Your appreciation for this review resource can be expressed by a visit to our sponsors.
(just a click will do it)

Google