Harry Potter!
Cinema Signal:

Dealing With Difficult People:
How to Deal With Nasty Customers, Demanding Bosses and Annoying Co-Workers


. "Rory O'Shea Was Here"

One way to deal with disability is courageously but, as this film and its principal character demonstrate, when splashy bravura is used to mask anger, pain and unnacceptance, courage may not be what's being expressed. Of course, one can always point out that the fully abled are in no position to know or to judge the cries for help that come from being confined for life to a wheelchair. That aside, the title character of the drama, takes self-assertion dangerously close to the realm of self-destruction.

The assisted living home in Dublin, known as the Carrigmore Home for the Disabled, contains a cross-section of impairments, from mild to the barely functional. In the case of Michael Connolly (Steven Robertson), who has grown up there, his cerebral palsy confines him to a wheelchair and to a speech impediment that makes verbal communication all but impossible.

But sometimes wonders occur, as in the case of Rory O'Shea's arrival on the scene. O'Shea (James MacAvoy) is also bound to a wheel chair. What he lacks in motor ability he makes up for with a sprightly mind, a quick wit, and a testy personality. Plus, he has no problem understanding Michael's every word. The symbiotic tie between this pair is immediate.

While Michael is one to accept his destiny, and to make the most of it, O'Shea is crawling out of his skin to achieve a greater amount of normality than reality is likely to permit. His purpose in life appears to be the effort to make people realize that his physical limitations do not represent his true identity. With his rebellious assertiveness and flinty attitude, his influence on Michael might not add up to mutual benefit, but Michael proves mature enough to maintain his own values and desires and to react in his own way to the alien world that O'Shea all but dumps on him.

After a bold adventure to a nightclub, during which the wheelchair pair meet ladies of the night, get into a scrap, and meet blond, lovely Siobhan (Romola Garai), they aren't inclined to withdraw to the controlled sedentary life that the institution demands. O'Shea proposes that they leave the institution for their own lives of independence and, to the consternation of institution supervisor Eileen (Brenda Fricker) (a mild alternative to Nurse Ratched of "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest"), they manage to shame Michael's powerful father into providing the means. They then land a personal-assistance grant from the three administrators of Ability Ireland, and move into a flat of their own.

Recognizing that they can't make do without the assistance of a caregiver, they track Siobhan down at her scuz job in a supermarket and convince her to take them on. Her beautiful and warm presence, however, only emphasizes their disabilities. With admirable integrity to reality, her proximity arouses emotions that can't be returned nor fulfilled.

The manner in which director Damien O'Donnell and writer Jeffrey Caine deal with this issue is a praiseworthy effort to keep their story out of the make- believe and the over-sentimental, wisely keeping the emotional elements grounded in reality. Further to the good, the elements of casting and performance elevate the narrowly focused drama above that of the run-of-the-mill disability-of-the-month movie.

Spiky-haired, handsome MacAvoy shows us how to be audacious and prominent without moving more than his face and two fingers. He has no disability in emoting while bound to the seat of a wheelchair. Garai is a composite of grace and sensitivity, with a beauty that is as internal as it is facial. Think of a cross blending of Drew Barrymore and Maria Bello -- an actress to watch. Fricker, as almost always, is a class act and richer in nuance and humanity than the stern administrator stereotype.

There is sorrow here but, at the end, one feels agreeable to having this obscure corner of society brought engagingly, if somewhat painfully, to our attention.

Click for full list of movie reviews





                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  


The DVD



List of reviews:
Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants




Steven Robertson, Romola Garai and James McAvoy
Care giving without illusions


Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors