INTERACTIVE (Rate the Review)

Subscribe to our update feeds:

Cinema Signal: Go! Strong appeal for all audiences

Sing Like an American Idol, Women's Edition
Everything You Need to Sing the Hits!

(Discounted Paperback (with CD) from Amazon)

. "The Proposal"

The first sighting of Sandra Bullock as forty-something Margaret Tate, book editor for a major publishing house in New York, is going to make the same impression on anyone who saw "The Devil Wears Prada" as Meryl Streep did. The charming and vulnerable Ms. Bullock has adopted a character that channels that fab lady in that surprise hit based on a boss only a polar bear could warm up to. The difference here, beside the setting, is how the office staff uses their network connections to warn each other of her arrival so that they can't be seen by her as slacking.

This stern lady's assistant is 30-ish male Andrew Paxton (Ryan Reynolds, "X-Men, Origins: Wolverine"), which is another difference, and the gender differential seems to be part of the office master's personal code of superiority over her minions. But Andrew is a bit of a surprise because he's found a way to maintain a degree of self-respect under the boss's withering demands and tests. In fact, you can't help but silently cheer the guy as he just won't let her put him down too far nor too frequently. As for his manuscript that she won't give a nod to, well, that's a bitter pill he hopes someday to spit out. Little does he realize the headway he's about to make with his professional career.

Accompanying her to an appointment at the Immigration Department, Andrew is at her side when she's informed by Mr. Gilbertson (Denis O'Hare) that she--a Canadian National--neglected to keep her visa requirements up and that her late application has been denied. She can't, therefore, work for an American company and is about to be deported. Yes, the boss from hell has been slack in her personal duties, and there's no way around the official rules and policies. Or... is there? Quick thinker that she is, she announces her pending marriage. To a U.S. National. Who? everyone asks. Why, Andrew, her beloved, now betrothed assistant.

But, she isn't fooling anyone. Mr. Gilbertson can read the situation clearly, thank you, and he demands that the pair return for a test of their knowledge of each other to prove the legitimacy of this quickly invented betrothal. Mr. Gilbertson makes it clear that they will be tested separately for their knowledge of each other, and the answers had better match up. So, if this is to fly, they've got a lot of catching up to do, across a major emotional divide.

Andrew's loyalty and ambition are on the line, and his first proposal is that, in order for him to go along with it, she's got to promise she'll advance him in the firm. Once she accepts that, he proposes that she makes a proper proposal of marriage on her knees out in the teeming streets of Manhattan. She then proposes that they take a crash course in each other's intimate details by going on a weekend trip up to his birthplace for the celebration of his grandma Annie's (Betty White) 90th birthday, which he had turned down when mom Grace Paxton (Mary Steenburgen) first called him about it.

This takes them to Sitka, Alaska, where Margaret makes a rather significant discovery about the man who's going to keep her in the USA--that he's from a very wealthy family. The Paxtons not only own every other vital store in the community but their hillside house is as big and fabulous as an embassy. Hmmm.

Mom and grandma are overjoyed by their arrival and set them up in their own bedroom, being wise to the ways of the modern world and creating a challenging awkwardness for the business arrangement between the couple. Dad, however, is coming from a different place--one not so accepting. Joe Paxton is clearly the head of the family and he hasn't ever taken it so well that his son has maintained his independence from his father's demands and the family business. Furthermore, he's not enchanted with his son marrying an older woman, sweet and lovely though she may be.

Not said, though intimated, is the more proper and expected bride for Andrew, his old high school and college girlfriend, Gertrude (Swedish Malin Akerman) who's been thinking the same thing.

Own it today! (Click on item link)
The 2-Disc DVD (with Digital Copy)
The 2-Disc Blu-ray Edition (with digital copy)

  • Additional Deleted Scenes (in HD on Blu-ray version - all others common to both)
  • Alternate Ending-with optional commentary by director Anne Fletcher and writer Peter Chiarelli
  • Deleted Scenes-with optional commentary by same as above.
  • Set Antics: Outtakes and Other Absurdities
  • Feature Audio Commentary by same as above.
  • By this time, the perfectionism of the office lord must be experiencing a modulation in her disposition if this comedy is going to go where we all want it to. Not saying that it does, but Margaret does seem to be folding in nicely with the family quirkiness even while maintaining that cool distance required of a marital arrangement.

    The sublety of change is the charge of the actors, who are exceptionally good at this, of Peter Chiarelli who scripted this journey of mismatched emigres to the New York business life, and of director, ex-choreographer Anne Fletcher ("27 Dresses") who doesn't allow the progression to flag at any moment and puts in our theaters a delightful return of Ms. Bullock, a splendid showing of Ryan Reynolds' exquisite timing and quick-witted flexibility in balancing the dynamics of the situation (so glad it wasn't Matthew McConnaughy), and an overall very respectable variation in the genre.

    In short, it works, it amuses, it satisfies. And, I can't remember the last time I said that about a romantic comedy.


    Click for full list of movie reviews

                                          ~~  Jules Brenner  

    Won't YOU start or join the discussion about this movie and/or review?
    Worries? Concerns? Want to know more? Just click the button...

    Opinion Section
    Comments from readers:
    Well written
    I've seen the movie and agree with the review
    Site rating: 8

    great movie...see it!!!

                                                               ~~ Herb 
    Well written, perceptive
    Site rating: 7

    I totally agree with the reviewer.

                                                               ~~ Jun Hoe 

    Release order
    Alphabetical order
    To Jbmovies
    (sample frames from movies photographed
    by Jules Brenner)

    All Reviews
    Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants

    Ryan Reynolds and Sandra Bullock
    Assistant to boss: get down on your knees if you want to marry me!

    Quick Note, yo:
    Your appreciation for this review resource can be expressed by a visit to our sponsors.
    (just a click will do it)