Cinema Signal:

Adam Sandler: America's Comedian

. "Punch-Drunk Love"

The opening sequence is at dawn, when we find our hero Barry Egan (Adam Sandler) sitting at his desk and talking strangely on the phone. He hangs up, ambles outside his manufacturing office in a semi-catatonic state. We then have a view up the street when two headlights approach at good speed. One, it turns out is a truck. It also turns out that it flips over with a small explosion, sliding off screen. Seconds later, a van pulls up directly outside the driveway of Egan's business and plops a harmonium on the street. Never are these pieces of business explained. The harmonium becomes an oft used prop but the truck is never again seen or alluded to.

I recount these details in an effort to make sense of the title. The person who was punch-drunk, it would seem, was Paul Thomas Anderson when he wrote the screenplay and directed the movie in a style that suggests struggle with conventions.

Okay, so it's off beat. So it's a whole different reality for Adam Sandler. So, it's full of gaping holes in logic, unanswered questions, erratic cutting, but is it bad? It has a profusion of confusion, a pseudo-autistic hero, and a stream of nonsequitirs. It's also not entirely bad.

What makes it win out in the end is the underlying love story, fully abled and abetted by a lustrous Emily Watson who plays Lena Leonard, a woman who is evidently in search of a shy wallflower given to bouts of serious withdrawal. It's not so easy to woo someone who is uncomfortable in your presence.

The strategies that she goes to, combined with a few moves of required aggresiveness, ultimately penetrates the thick wall of fear and discomfort surrounding Egan. As he deals with that he must also deal with the Arizona-based ring of scam artists that Egan made contact with when he dialed up a sex service. They come to wreck him when he makes demands to get his money back. The outcome of this story arc will thrill and amaze you.

Director Anderson's style of erratic behavior and personally fabricated reality (see "Magnolia") seems a good mask for Sandler's dire limitations as an actor. The reason to see it, though, is neither of those things. It is Emily Watson, who finds a way in her stores of emotional depth to elevate the comedic enterprise to a fascinating study of attraction in something you wouldn't expect to be satisfying circumstances.

Click for full list of movie reviews

                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  

The Soundtrack Album

Opinion Section
Comments from readers:
This review adds meaning to the movie for me
Rating: 9

I was wondering how to translate the title in Albanian. Some of the comments found in your site and in others have helped me crystallize a title in my mind.

                                               ~~ Loran G.
                              (translator, Tirana, Albania)

Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants

Emily Watson and Adam Sandler, a curious attraction.

Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)

Best selling DVDs!