Cuba After
Communism
Cinema Signal:

Fidel's Cuba:
A Revolution in Pictures


. "The Lost City"

If there was as much talent in the making of this film as there was ego bloating it to painful levels, it would have turned into something much more compelling. The best that can be said for it is that it conveys an idea of the issues for Cubans during the last days of the Batista regime and early days of the Castro takeover. If anyone was wondering why so many Cubans left their land and have flooded out since, risking life and forsaking relationships, see the movie.

But, unless you have a great capacity for sentimental embellishment without relief, I have to say that the main moments I remember are operatic farewells, enough tears to fill the Hollywood reservoir and no quarter given in emotional excess.

It's 1958. The tyrannical dictator Fulgencio Batista (Juan Fernandez) is hanging on to power and oppressing his people. Fidel Castro (Gonzalo Menendez) and Che Guevara (Jsu Garcia) are in the hills with their army, attacking and terrorizing the countryside as circumstances and ammunition allow. Havana is roiled up. The scent of change is in the air and people are taking sides. Through all this, Fico Fellove runs the city's classiest musical nightclub, attracting the best native talent to his stage.

The club's success is so conspicous it attracts the interest of the major mob figure, Meyer Lansky (Dustin Hoffman) who makes an offer. Incurring the threat of the gangster's punishment, Fico turns it down. Fico is true to his entrepreneurial creation, just as he is to the special quality of his nation. His nightclub symbolizes the essence of Havana. Why he then hires a gagman whom we know as "The Writer" (Bill Murray) is anybody's guess but the Murray standup style is somehow integrated into the serious tapestry of calamity and romance.

Fico participates in many meals and conversations with his family, especially with his philosophical and loving father, a professor. His brothers are problems, with one taking the lead in an ill fated attack on Batista's palace and losing his life to the the chief of the dictator's police in a followup retaliation. When he dies, Fico lives up to the promise he made to his brother to care for his widow, the statuesque Aurora (Ines Sastre) in the event of his death.

The relationship is slowly recognized as mutual and intense but, when Fidel takes over the country in December of that year, her husband's sacrifice is recognized by the communist general and she's acclaimed for it. She responds to the honor by joining Fidel's cause as one of his inner circle. Fico responds by seeing the handwriting on the wall and fleeing the country until Fidel takes his turn, presumably, in disappearing from the stage of Cuba's leadership as surely as the parade into oblivion of his predecessors.

Of course, as we all know, it didn't turn out that way. And, Garcia, who directed from G. Cabrera Infante's script, has wanted to make of movie out of this part of the Cuban tragedy every since he left Havana at age 5 1/2. As a screen presence, he's way up there with the handsomest. As a filmmaker, unfortunately, he's done a collection of arias. His characters don't just say goodbye. No one departs in less than five minutes. There's no expression of love or inner feelings under seven (or so it felt). There are extended hugs and back-slapping encouragements galore. Forgets cuts. Understatement is the alien concept. And it goes two hours and twenty three minutes.

Colors and textures are very well captured in the cinematography and production design, but performances suffer. What talent is there is blunted by clinging to sentiment to the last drop of emotional bile. Many (not all) supporting players seem more Garcia paisanos than players who might have, under more skillful and objective choices, added a greater contribution of depth or originality to the piece. But creative objectivity is what is in such short supply. If it were oxygen we'd all suffocate. Discipline is as rare as a Cuban cigar in Los Angeles. Garcia allows himself so much overindulgence, the seriousness of his story wallows in so much excess, we're looking for a lifeboat to rescue us from the tsunami of theatrics.

The events show a time of great trouble for a romantic and creative people, but I didn't come to the theatre in order to be punished for it. Talk about oppression. By the 2nd hour with seemingly no end in sight, I was beginning to feel trapped by a tyrant who wouldn't let go.

Click for full list of movie reviews





                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  



Opinion Section
Comments from readers:
Well written
This review will influence me to see this movie.
I think the point he's trying to drive home, is people having to flee their countries and start over. It's a story with which many Cubans in Miami can identify. Outside of the Cuban exile society, few understand the big deal. Few have probably had to flee their homeland in such a way.
                                                           ~~ Elias 
[Ed. note: We appreciate receiving this reader's thoughts, but he doesn't give non-Cuban people much credit for sympathy or empathy nor for the ability to understand the desire to flee a dictator's control even with the great difficulty of starting over. Lest anyone further misunderstand, the criticism in this review is about the movie's style of storytelling, not at all about the history it's based on nor the feelings of the Cuban people.]

I've seen the movie and I disagree with the review
Site rating: 10

The movie is a work of art. Excellent.

                                                           ~~ Falco 
Off base
I've seen the movie and I disagree with the review

Great movie about the real Cuba, thank you Andy Garcia! if you have not live under the monster named Fidel Castro...DO NOT REVIEW THIS MOVIE!!!!

                                                           ~~ Rae G. 
[Ed. note: Tell you what Rae, if you don't tell us what we're qualified to review, we won't tell you what you're qualified to read. Deal?] Very well written
I've seen the movie and I agree with the review
Site rating: 10

Very few actors become excellent directors; I can only think of one, Clint Eastwood. Garcia looks great and needs a director to reign him in.

                                                           ~~ Thomas M. 



Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants





Andy Garcia and Ines Sastre
A great love, a bitter separation
Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)