Cinema Signal: Flawed, forgivable only for a limited audience.


Living with Life-Threatening Illness:
A Guide for Patients, Their Families, and Caregivers

. "Monsieur Ibrahim" (aka, "Monsieur Ibrahim et les Fleurs du Coran")

Because this story is so intent on making the adoption of a young Jewish boy by an older Muslim man plausible, characters and situation had to be contrived to clear away logical and cultural impediments. Despite questions of credibility, director Fran‡ois Depeyron achieves more of what he aimed to do than his underwritten screenplay would seem to justify.

It's a Paris neighborhood for the underclass, a place where prostitutes take up their posts along the street and where young Moses (Pierre Boulanger in a first time role) watches them ply their trade from his modest apartment where he lives with his father (Gilbert Melik). Instead of wanting the latest boardgame or bicycle he's seen in a store, this 13-year old develops a strong hankering for one of the women on the street. Driven by hormonal awakenings, he breaks open his kiddie bank and bravely offers what it contained to the lady of his dreams. She turns him down, but he's taken for deflowering by another streetwalker with a more generous attitude.

Having accomplished the task of establishing him manhood, he returns to his apartment to greet his morose and distant father with dinner after a drab day of menial work in an office. Needing something for the meal, dad sends Moses out to "the Arab", who turns out to be Monsieur Ibrahim (Omar Sharif), the proprieter of the neighborhood general store. As Ibrahim explains to the boy that he's not Arab, he bestows on him the more familiar, affectionate name, Momo. And, as he forgives Momo his bit of shoplifting, we and Momo recognize the storekeeper's gentle nature and uncritical warmth.

This is in stark contrast to the callous treatment Momo receives at home, where he's subjected to constant criticism in harsh, demanding tones. More than once, the demeaning treatment by his father chases Momo out of the house. Having been abandoned by his mother and never knowing his older brother, he turns more and more to Ibrahim, who provides a needed comfort and a growing emotional attachment. Momo readily submits to Ibrahim's lessons about life, running a store, and his undemanding reference to his Koran. Though Ibrahim is a Muslim, he's not a fundamentalist, allowing an unusual bond to develop despite the religious divide. His gilded book, always at Ibrahim's side, is one of mystery and beauty to the wide-eyed Jewish youngster.

Therein, we have the central message of the piece. When people are open and curious, when humanity overrides repressive mandates of religion, cross cultural ties may flourish.

The relationship pays off when dad loses his job, abandons Momo, and commits suicide under the wheels of a train, shifting the emphasis now to the more demanding question of a teenager's survival without a parent. In an entrepreneurial spirit, if not a shortsighted one, the orphan hocks whatever's in the apartment for another taste of the streetwalker's favors. But the yearning of most importance is the relationship with his older friend.

How convenient to put this match together by creating a father who is morose, maladjusted, a borderline sociopath and to be conveniently taken off the scoreboard. This contrivance might be overlooked because of the essential positives in the package, which include unique moments of caring and a coming of age in unexpected circumstances. Its handling of religious themes and racial barriers are designed to avoid any hint of controversy or condemnation.

Both actors fit their parts well, with Boulanger audaciously personable and Sharif endearing and patient. As an elder statesman of the acting craft Sharif is realizing his maturity with engaging depth and consummate skill. He nearly wins us over through a last act that abandons drama while it treats us to the new father-son relationship on a road trip. But the extended sentimentality of Depeyron's idealization is too much even for the actors' gifts as the story reaches for poignancy while closing in cloudy ambiguity with a melancholy aftertaste.

Click for full list of movie reviews





                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  


The DVD




Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants





Pierre Boulanger and Omar Sharif
Plying the streets of Paris together

Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)