Cinema Signal:

Blowing the Whistle on the Christian Church in America:
The Hypocrisy and Double Standards Exposed

. "The Gospel of John"

The use for which this film seems to have been made is a bible study class. It's hardly commercially viable for theatrical release unless there are more intellectually curious filmgoers than I suspect there is. While I question the distributor's decision to release it in theatres, (perhaps because of its film festival success) its tie-in to the theme of the holidays makes sense, along with the fact that anyone who decides to pay current boxoffice prices knows from the title exactly what to expect.

I mean, exactly. Its publicity touts that its script is directly from the pages of the American Bible Society's Good News Bible, dedicated by its producer, Toronto-based Visual Bible International Inc., to present the bible on film as it was written. The problem for theatre goers looking for entertainment or a more mainstream-satisfying example of edification through dramatization is all the above. Its adherence to that biblical script makes for turgid going.

Led by Royal Shakespeare Co. member Henry Ian Cusick in the role of Jesus, the story traces his life from the time he announces that he's the messiah to an unreceptive audience in ancient Judea to his reappearances after death. In the course of that dramatization, we hear his proseletyzing words and phrases hundreds of times. Long after we receive the message and in the face of countless instances of doubt, even by his followers, the phrases are repeated ad nauseum, a mind-numbing mantra, drowning a mainstream audience in a flood of oversell.

This study in literalism allows for no bond or tie to any character. The depiction of the best actor in it is way too lofty for an attachment to grow. Caring about the outcome is purely a function of a belief in the story it so painstakingly recounts, but not from any effect of performance or writing. Such literalism doesn't function as art.

Of course, the biblical context and the producer's mission suggests why this might be appropriate to such a film. But, this faithfulness to scripture is death to engaging drama. It is in this sense, and only in this sense, that I find considerable fault with it and envision its survival in theatres as brief, quickly settling into very specialized cinema houses and of great usefulness to religious training in bible classes. That it might stick around at all and, in fact, go into profit, is more a function of very low production costs than to its appeal as entertainment. Its educational value is estimable but doesn't redeem it as worthy of commercial release.

If this vision of its theatrical prospects holds true, the faithful should rush to see it as early as they can during its commercial run.

[Editor's note:
It is not our intention to disrespect the
Gospel of John. Its release as a commercial
movie venture exposes it to critique in
commercial terms and our comments should be
understood to apply to it in that context.

[Editor's note:
For a dramatization of Lutheranism, see this year's "Luther."

Click for full list of movie reviews

                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  

Opinion Section
Comments from readers:
Well written
I disagree with the review
Rating: 4

I do agree that the target audience for "The Gospel of John" is narrow and that being faithful to scripture is "death in a dramatic sense", but the production quality and acting far exceeds anything previously put forth by the faith community.

Despite its faults, the niche approach, as evidenced by the "Passion" marketing, can mobilize the target audience, engendering box office success.

I love the writing style(s) of the reviewers. Good command of the English language and great breakdowns.

                                                      ~~ Chad

Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants

The last supper, as staged in "The Gospel of John"

Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)