Cinema Signal:

A Nail, a Rose:
And Other Stories
By Madeleine Bourdouxhe

. "Gilles' Wife" (aka, "La Femme de Gilles")

What a harmonious little household in the French countryside this is. Gilles (Clovis Cornillac) delights his loving wife Elisa (Emmanuelle Devos) as a masterful husband who satisfies her in every way, from his duties in bed to his duties as a caring father for their two girls. Idyllic... until Gilles takes a fancy to Elisa's treacherous sister, Victorine (Laura Smet).

It doesn't take long for Elisa to understand the double betrayal. Gilles is too obtuse and Victorine way too selfish to hide it from her. In fact, the sheer insensitivity of this pair of betrayers is displayed so egregiously and publically it can hardly be believed. Elisa isn't enraged. She martials her internal forces with minimal outward appearance in a display of forbearance that could qualify her for sainthood. She holds to the belief that Gilles will get over it despite his denials.

That is, when they finally talk about it. Dialogue in any form is nearly absent from this house. When Victorine dances with another man in front of Gilles and Elisa, his jealousy ignites and it's he who flies into a rage. This dummy conceals nothing and his wife says nothing.

Emmanuelle Devos devotedly centralizes a woman's frustration and her cowardly adaptation to disintegrating circumstances with a man whose sensitivity seems to have been arrested at birth. Her adaptability, created by director Frederic Fonteyne from a script by Philippe Blasband adapted from the novel by Madeleine Bourdouxhe, is suspect as a credible basis for a hot, steamy romp in French infidelity and melodrama.

For me, its only virtue lies in putting Devos to work. An actress of considerable depth and a juicy range of expressiveness ("The Beat That My Heart Skipped," "Kings and Queen" her talent isn't the master of this annoyingly passive character. And when no one in the small town cares or even makes note of Elisa's publically displayed marital insults, the credibility of the story bursts and tensions turn into pretensions. It comes off as reaching too far for originality, a sense that is only tied up with a ribbon by a completely dumb and desperate twist ending.

It lost me, but maybe it's a French thing.

Click for full list of movie reviews





                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  


The DVD




Opinion Section
Comments from readers:
Well written, perceptive
This review will influence me to read more by and recommend this reviewer
I'll get my local newspaper to hire this reviewer
I've seen the movie and agree with the review
Site rating: 9

Having already read half a dozen other reviews of the movie, I was angry and frustrated with the quality (or lack of it) of reviews on the net. I just chanced on this one review, which has mollified me somewhat as I prepare to go to bed ( I am still quite angry at the bare-facedness of people who watch a movie and then half-assedly scribble something and get paid for making me waste my time reading them! As a woman, I find this movie (and presumably, the novel) humiliating, annoying and disgusting. The actress acts like a retarded cow but that must have been her brief, and if so, she acts really well. The actor didn't leave an impression. His muscley arms did!

                                                           ~~ Sheba 



Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants





Emmanuelle Devos and Clovis Cornillac
Marital stupidity in the French countryside.
Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)