Harry Potter!
Cinema Signal:
. "Evelyn"

The British Isles have had their taste of success in the U.S. boxoffice with low-budget, unambitious fare. There was "The Full Monty", "Brassed Off", and "The Trial of Ned Kelly". So, it's small wonder that every year some product from those cousins abroad will come forth in another attempt at a similar outcome. It just goes to prove that any formula for success is elusive and thinking you have a movie with the same elements that proved so effective in the past would garner a repeat. The latest in this thread of packaged imports is "Evelyn". It doesn't do it.

It starts off with a plus. It's star, Pierce Brosnan, is very familiar from the Bond series, last seen in "Die Another Day", currently running big. Next plus for "Eleanor" is surrounding him with a few other Irish-identified names, the likes of Aidan Quinn (actually born in Illinois) and Stephen Rea, and Englishman Alan Bates.

(Where is Michael Caine when we need him?)

In any case, it would seem they depleted the island of just about anyone who could bring commercial zing to the good ol' American audience. Then, to brighten that outlook even more, they corral Julianna Margulies of "ER" fame.

With a simplistic by-the-numbers script and a style of shoving subtleties in your face like it was to be shown to no one with an IQ above 80 or an age below 12, the film's creative chemistry is wasted.

Based on a real incident in Irish jurisprudence, the story outlines the case of a father, two sons, a daughter by the name of Evelyn, and a wife who abandons the lot. Turns out that Desmond Doyle, the now single father is not allowed, by the established "Children's Act of 1941", to raise his children without the consent of the mother. In this case she's so long gone, and for good, that this is not an option.

But, fighting for them is, and Doyle's fight begins with himself. After being turned away by the government minister who presides over the terms of the Children's Act and protects it like his appointment was at stake, Doyle, a painter by trade, realizes that he needs to gain continuous, reliable employment. To win the affections of temporary barmaid Bernadette (Julianna Margulies) he must conquer his drinking habit.

On the way to those goals, he manages to enlist the aid of a powerful legal team (Stephen Rea, Aidan Quinn, Alan Bates) and after being soundly rejected by the lower court, his legal team takes the matter to the supreme court of Ireland where, it seems, constitutional issues are heard. Their study of several articles of that document show that the Children's Act is in contravention of the Irish constitution. The only problem is that the statute is ingrained and, to allow otherwise is a bitter pill of a people's victory the court and the ministers of government won't swallow. They dissemble all they can in order to twist the interpretation in order to avoid a reform that logic demands.

How it ends is not for us to divulge here. Let's say the acting is professional, the screenplay doesn't make very much of that, it's fun seeing Pierce Brosnan shed of his James Bond personna and divulging the hidden down-to-earth mannerisms of a pro who should get out more. Finally, there's the title character portrayer, Sophie Vavasseur, who is just as charming as the piece requires.

Yes, "Evelyn" is heartwarming and, yes, it's inspirational. Many will be taken in by it. The trouble enters the picture when it it pushes those themes down your throat, to the point of making itself an outright tract on touchy, feely platitudes and ill-advised flourishes. It's called corn. The most egregious of this is the melodramatic appearance of the preposterous "angel rays" -- just when little Evelyn is in the witness box and in need of a little celestial confidence building. This kind of shameless movie mentality went out with separated beds, or so one might have wished.

Among the legal team there is no anger, anxiety or much beyond a good ol' boys insouciant trip to the library. These big guns barely crease their ascots as this major legal battle is put together -- little more than a romp for these gentlemen, both as unchallenged actors reading simplistic lines and as the legal tacticians they so feebly portray.

Because of such Sunday school simplicity, the virtues of the film are inadequate to lift the picture out of a middling level of dramatic interest or to inspire much by way of wide admiration by any but the arch and indiscrimanate romantics out there. But, Brosnan's work shows such a high level of sincerity and dedication that we encourage him to continue in the non-Bond mold. His intelligence and modulation shows through and will see him through, given better developed material.

As fine a director as Bruce Beresford has been in the past, he should have known better than to allow such superficial trivialities and celestial nonsense to seep into the staging. After all, he directed "Tender Mercies" and "Driving Miss Daisy", two films graced with superb screenwriting. This screenplay by Paul Pender ("Cadfael" 1994 TV series) is not that -- it might have been directed by some Sunday school teacher who read a book on movie making. The result, for this movielover, is too much cloying, bathetic blarney and stock characters.

The soundtrack includes a number by the singular Van Morrison but does not incorporate two marvelous traditional folk songs sung convincingly and well by Brosnan in the picture.

Click for full list of movie reviews

                                      ~~  Jules Brenner  

The Soundtrack Album

The DVD Album

Opinion Section
Comments from readers:
I've seen the movie and disagree with the review
Site rating: 8

I disagree with the reviwer due to watching the movie and towards the end could feel my eyes watering up. I know that this happens in real life so maby that is why I feel so strongly.

                                                           ~~ Brian 
[Ed. note: I fully respect your opinion and how this film affected you. And thanks for not downrating the site and my efforts because of our disagreement over the film.]

Release order
Alphabetical order
To Jbmovies
(sample frames from movies photographed
by Jules Brenner)

All Reviews
Books, DVDs, Music, Restaurants

Little Sophie Vavasseur as "Evelyn"

Help us to continue
bringing you these reviews...
visit our sponsors (just a click will do it)