Since seeing the movie, the thing I'm trying most to manage is my anger at
not leaving the theater after 20 minutes of this inane drivel. Now, if you
want to know what I really think of it, read
on.
For this big-time cast, it's the usual for Adam Sandler and the worst I've
seen for Jack Nicholson. But what really puts it in the cellar are
writer David Dorfman and director Peter Segal's lame concoction. I mention
their names to put the blame where it belongs. I'm also venting a little,
here.
This is a comedy based on two guys meeting up and producing a situation full
of laughs. But, the formula goes sour from the git go. Dave Buznik (Adam
Sandler) is a shy, repressed guy who speaks softly and is accused by a
dominatrix stewardess of harrassment. When she brings out a guy who might be
an air marshall or just a beefy steward, he gets even more gross intimidation
and unsupported accusations. Our gutless hero takes the verbal beating with
innefectual denials and stuttering gutteral noises, making him prime meat for
Buddy Rydell (Jack Nicholson), a therapist in anger management who is in the
seat next to him. Imagine.
It turns out that the anger manager uses his position as a therapist to wreak
the havoc of domination over his vulnerable patients and, to do reality
another bad turn, has influence with the court, which sees to it that
innocent, unjustly maligned people are brought under his control for further
life wreckage.
This is so implausible and unpalatable, it's not funny.
The only thing that managed to keep me in my seat is Marisa Tomei who, as
Linda, Buddy's girlfriend, is farther out of the wind of comedic disaster
that blows through this script than most of the others. But, my whispers to
her to get the mess more on track went unnoticed. I had to settle just for
her tempered loveliness as her beau struggles against a tide of emotional
dizziness to arrive at a commitment.
Cast talents such as John Tuturro, Luis Guzman and John C. Reilly go along
with the misconception as well, and can't rise to a rescue of the prolongued
feebleness.
I get the Sandler schtick. His success and popularity is based on the
introverted hero who finds a way to come out of his shell and triumph over
adversity. Keaton and Chaplin created their classics out of this gist, and
Sandler has found how to make the formula work for him. Even in so terrible
an adaptation of it as this excuse for a comedy, it still works magic at the
boxoffice. This movie is a financial success. Who'da thunk it? That great
big audience out there who could care less about taste and classic cleverness,
that's who.
After this film, we tend to share Dave's feelings of inadequacy. But we
didn't need a movie to cause them.

~~ Jules Brenner